WasteServ welcomes the Court of Appeal judgment annulling a decision by the Information and Data Protection Appeals Tribunal, chaired by Dr Anna Mallia, which The Shift News had portrayed as a “landmark ruling against WasteServ as CEO slammed”.
The Court found that the tribunal had misunderstood the merits of the case, focusing on commercial confidentiality – an argument WasteServ had never raised – rather than addressing its defence that the information sought was protected under the Freedom of Information Act because it involved personal data.
The Court concluded that the Tribunal’s decision lacked even the minimum consideration necessary for a reader to understand WasteServ's defence, and this fundamental shortcoming invalidated the ruling.
WasteServ considers it particularly regrettable that The Shift presented the original ruling as a landmark defeat for WasteServ and its CEO Richard Bilocca, when the Court has now found such fundamental deficiencies in the tribunal’s consideration of the case.
The proceedings before the tribunal arose from a Freedom of Information request submitted by The Shift’s Caroline Muscat in early 2023, seeking engagement contracts and vacancy notices relating to Mr Bilocca and lawyer Pearl Agius.
WasteServ promptly provided Mr Bilocca’s contract and its extension, while explaining that Dr Agius's personal data deserved the protection afforded by law.
The Court has referred the case back to the tribunal for fresh consideration. WasteServ fully respects this process and will continue to cooperate, confident that its arguments will receive the careful consideration they deserve.